What’s in Store for LEED?
Second Comment Period Open for LEED 2012
By Matthew J. DeVries
In what has been unofficially called LEED 2012, the U.S. Green Building Council
(“USGBC”) opened the second public comment period from August 1 to September 14,
2011 for the next version of the LEED® rating system. According to the USGBC, a
public comment period helps ensure that LEED continues to be at the vanguard of
innovative design construction and operation of buildings and communities.
The final version, which is expected to be released in late 2012, has some
noteworthy proposed changes. First, LEED 2009 has 9 prerequisites and 49
credits, while the new draft has 15 prerequisites and 49 credits. Second, there
are now 10 different categories in the new draft, as opposed to 7 categories in
the prior versions. The three new categories, as well as some changes and
additions to the existing categories, are explained in more detail below.
Overall, these changes are either new credit categories, changes to the
technical requirements, or revised point distribution.
Integrated Process (IP): This new category is intended to support and encourage
project team integration required by a LEED project and to streamline the
application and certification process. Following the first comment period, this
credit was revised to include four sections that reward project teams for early
analysis of building and site systems, various charrettes throughout the design
process, and meeting training requirements for certain construction and
operations personnel. In addition, the LEED AP who is assigned to the project
must have relevant specialty area accreditation.
Location and Transportation (LT): This new category consists of credits from the
old “Sustainable Sites” category that relate to the location of the project. It
also includes provisions such as a “Bicycle Network, Storage and Shower Rooms”
and “Walkable Project Site” credits. The second public comment draft includes
many changes to the names of the credits to better reflect the requirements.
Sustainable Sites (SS): Language has been added to clarify “Brownfield
Redevelopment” to require actual remediation of the site to meet local, state or
federal cleanup standards. In fact, under the second public comment draft this
credit was renamed “Brownfield Remediation.” Significantly, "Healthcare" was
added to the list of applicable building types to the prerequisites for
"construction activity pollution prevention" and "environmental site
assessment". Other revisions are recommended to the “Protect or Restore Habitat”
and the “Open Space” credits. The two storm-water credits from LEED 2009 have
been rolled into one credit called “Rainwater Management.” The requirements for
“Light Pollution Reduction” include a new calculation method.
Water Efficiency (WE): Although a couple credits are renamed, much of the
requirements are unchanged. The new “Landscape Water Use Reduction” prerequisite
applies to projects with a minimum of 1,000 square feet of exterior vegetated
surface area and applies to all irrigation water, regardless of source. Another
new “Appliance and Process Water Use Reduction” prerequisite seeks to reduce the
burden on water supply and wastewater systems by increasing the water efficiency
of appliances and water-consuming processes. Finally, there is a new credit for
“Cooling Tower Makeup Water,” which seeks to conserve water used for cooling
tower makeup while controlling microbes and corrosion in the water system.
Energy and Atmosphere (EA): There are some wording changes and revisions to
threshold requirements throughout this category. Notably, “Refrigerant
Management” prerequisites for all rating systems were eliminated from the first
public comment period, but reintroduced for the second public comment period.
The “Minimum Energy Performance” prerequisite changes how energy costs and
savings are calculated, while the "Optimize Energy Performance" credit changes
some of its metrics and requires that modeling be used in design as opposed to
performance compliance. Finally, a new credit for Demand Response is intended to
reduce regional carbon emissions and improve optimization of electric
generation, transmission and distribution resources.
Materials and Resources (MR): Some of the wording of the provisions in this
category have changed, but most of the requirements remain the same as in the
LEED 2009 provisions. The “Recycled Content” prerequisite, which was added for
the first public comment period, has now been eliminated due to lack of market
support. Construction and Demolition Waste Management Planning is another new
prerequisite, that now requires a specific waste management policy. A few other
new credits were deleted from the second draft, while many new credits appear,
such as nonstructural materials and environmentally preferable products.
Indoor Environmental Quality (EQ): The most notable change in this category
transforms the "Construction IAQ Management Plan" into a prerequisite. Low
Emitting Interiors is a new credit that addresses the material concentrations of
contaminates. The interior is now split into five systems (floors, ceilings,
walls, insulation and furniture) for credit calculations. Also, the Daylight and
Quality Views credits have major revisions. Significantly, the second draft of
the prerequisites attempts to be more harmonize with the ASHRAE standards.
Performance (PF): This category has a new prerequisite for Water Metering, which
intends to promote water efficiency by providing accurate consumption data to
building managers. Notably, there is a another new prerequisite for
"Building-Level Energy Metering", which is set up to meter, track and share
building-level energy resource use. One such way is to participate in the
USGBC’s Building Performance Partnership for a five year period. The
"Fundamental Commissioning and Verification" prerequisite adds some major
commissioning agent tasks from EA category. Finally, there are some additional
provisions to address the verification provisions of LEED 2009 under the new
"Reconcile Projected and Actual Energy Performance" credit, the intent of which
is to provide for the ongoing accountability of the building energy consumption
Other notable changes include rewording of the Innovation (IN) credit. For LEED-Schools,
the project can now achieve up to four points for innovation. Also, the Regional
Priority (RP) credits, which are identified by regional councils and chapters,
now include priorities for social equity and public health. If you want more
information about the new changes or the public comment period, you can visit
is a member of the Construction Service Group of Stites & Harbison, PLLC, and is
a LEED® Accredited Professional. Matt lives in Nashville and is the founder of
www.bestpracticesconstructionlaw.com. You can reach the author at
Click Here to
for Your FREE DCD Magazine Subscription